Shortbread: FAIL.
Remember what I said about not trying to rush your Scottish Shortbread? Well, it's often hardest to take your own advice.
I made another batch of Shortbread with very poor results.
First, I used brown sugar. This was a mistake. It gave a nice color, but not enough sweetness and you just can't properly cream butter with brown sugar. I will use bland and boring old white refined sugar next time like the recipe says to use. I may add a little brown sugar, but will stick to the ingredients and portions listed in the recipe.
I also turned the oven up from 300 to 325. BAD IDEA.
And then, I left it to cook for 35 (to almost 40) minutes. Another resoundingly bad idea.
This batch was flat, dry and over baked, however, as it was sitting out on the porch to cool, out of the corner of my eye I saw my cat trying to steal one of the shortbread rounds right off of the pan. I am surprised she didn't burn herself, but at least she liked it.
The point is: Use the listed ingredients in the proper portions, BE PATIENT! and cook it in a slow oven.
Scottish Shortbread
1 cup of butter
1/2 cup sugar
2 1/2 cups of flour
Cream sugar and butter then cut in flour.
Refrigerate dough for 2 hours.
Cut the dough in two and pat into two 7 to 8 inch circles about 1/3 of an inch thick each. Fork prick to make 16 wedges.
Bake on an ungreased cookie sheet at 300 for 30 minutes.
COOL, then remove from pan and place on cooling rack. Cool more, remember I said these cookies can not be rushed....
Comments
I've also heard that the Scots will mix a little rice flour in the white flour, to give it a good crunch.
I watched this chef on scotlandontv.tv and he kept saying something about CASTER sugar? And another chef called the flour something something flour. I should go back and check.
I am very disappointed in this batch and want to throw it out, but all that butter... what a waste... may be I'll just feed it to the cat as a treat once in awhile since she tried to steal it off of the cooling rack!
My next two things on the list are American, Funnel cake and Dumplings for chicken and dumplings. Flour and I don't get on well together so I am trying things...
And yes, I was thinking about castor sugar as an alternative. I've gotten it at Whole Foods for my tea. Deeelicious! It's a Brit thing, mos def.
Brown sugar isn't it? wow. OK, I'm going to try it, when this temp job is over and I can spend time in the kitchen again. thanks for recipe info and cautions!!!!!!!
Let us know how the next batch turns out!
I wondered about the fridge. I put in for two hours but when I take it out it's rock hard. So last time I had to rework it to get it to flatten... overworked dough yeah.... Is 2 hours too long to chill, should I let it warm up before cutting it in half and trying to flatten it out?
I will try again as soon as I get more butter...