Shortbread: FAIL.

Comments

I adore shortbread. If you're looking for a caramel-like flavor, you might try one of the organic, unbleached sugars from a health food store. Regular brown sugar has a much higher moisture content which definitely would affect your shortbread but the unbleached cane sugars might be a good bet.

I've also heard that the Scots will mix a little rice flour in the white flour, to give it a good crunch.
Yeah, I also forgot to say I USED A MIXER TO CREAM THE BUTTER. VERY, VERY BAD! Shortbread likes to be touched softly by its' maker.

I watched this chef on scotlandontv.tv and he kept saying something about CASTER sugar? And another chef called the flour something something flour. I should go back and check.

I am very disappointed in this batch and want to throw it out, but all that butter... what a waste... may be I'll just feed it to the cat as a treat once in awhile since she tried to steal it off of the cooling rack!

My next two things on the list are American, Funnel cake and Dumplings for chicken and dumplings. Flour and I don't get on well together so I am trying things...

Flour and I don't get on well together so I am trying things...

Aren't you brave! So many people drop stuff they find a little tricky without figuring it out. Good for you!

And yes, I was thinking about castor sugar as an alternative. I've gotten it at Whole Foods for my tea. Deeelicious! It's a Brit thing, mos def.
I always seem to end up with too much flour. Always dry and heavy. I keep trying... and starving...
[this is good]
*sigh* shortbread.love it.Never made it.
Brown sugar isn't it? wow. OK, I'm going to try it, when this temp job is over and I can spend time in the kitchen again. thanks for recipe info and cautions!!!!!!!
My ex- tried perfecting shortbread recipes for years. These are some tips he discovered alont the way and may make a difference... Though you may already know them.

If you work the dough with your hands, you must be quick. Too long and the heat from your hands will begin to melt the butter. Heavy, solid dough. Yuck.

Leave little chunks of butter to melt and "aerate" the dough, rather than blending it in completely. It will be delicate and light.

Working flour too much activates the gluten, making it tough. Good for bread, bad for pastries and biscuits. Work it quickly and efficiently to incorporate ingredients.

Refrigerate the shortbreads before they go in the oven. That way they won't melt before they bake.
Let us know how the next batch turns out!
I do tend over-stir (overwork) my doughs and mixes. I've known I do that for simply endless, I wonder why I don't knock it off? Or in Scots, gonnae no dae that... I think that's right for stop doing that.

I wondered about the fridge. I put in for two hours but when I take it out it's rock hard. So last time I had to rework it to get it to flatten... overworked dough yeah.... Is 2 hours too long to chill, should I let it warm up before cutting it in half and trying to flatten it out?

I will try again as soon as I get more butter...
They do ask to refridgerate the dough, to let it "rest." But then, after you form the shortbreads into whatever shape you want and they're on the cookie sheet, put the whole cookie sheet back in the fridge till they chill. Then pop them right in the oven from the fridge. I think you'll notice a difference. Good luck, brumblegunny!!

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in

thegrumblebunny

About Me

thegrumblebunny
United States
LIFE IS LIKE TRYING TO SWEEP A DIRT FLOOR WITH A FEATHER DUSTER.

Neighborhood

Explore friends, family, friends & family, or entire neighborhood.

Archives